What you are really buying
Few companies shop for an SEO agency because they love search. They shop because organic traffic has stalled, a migration went wrong, or a competitor keeps appearing above them. That urgency is exactly why so many agency selections go badly: the brief is vague, proposals are compared on monthly price, and the contract measures activity instead of outcomes.
The ground has also moved. Google launched AI Overviews and AI Mode in France on 22 July 2026, according to Google's French blog, after both had reached most of Europe in 2025. The same announcement mentions a new Search Console control that lets site owners decide whether their content appears in Google's generative AI features. Any agency you hire now has to work across classic results, AI summaries and conversational search, and be honest about what it can and cannot measure in each.
Before you compare a single proposal, write down three things:
- The business problem: lost rankings after a redesign, weak category pages, no visibility in a new market, or poor conversion on traffic you already have.
- The constraint: who will implement changes, whether that is your developers, a CMS vendor or the agency itself.
- The metric that matters: qualified leads, organic revenue, indexed pages that actually earn impressions. Not "rankings" in isolation.
Once that is on paper, the right type of partner is usually obvious, and so are the proposals that do not fit. If the real problem is messaging or content rather than crawling and indexing, start with a content strategy engagement instead of a pure technical retainer.